SIP Construction

SIP (Structural Insulated Panel) construction was developed by the timber industry to be a competitor to ICF as a cost effective and energy efficient system for building homes.

SIPs are an MMC system made in a factory and because they are relatively thin in section they provide a high level of insulation without occupying valuable internal floorspace. However, SIP construction is an expensive way to build a timber framed house and inherits all the downsides of traditional timber construction, along with some new ones.

Disadvantages of SIP Construction

Structural Insulated Panel (SIPs) consist of 2 outer layer boards (typically OSB) surrounding rigid foam insulation.

The primary drawback of SIP Construction is that the building has very low Thermal Mass, just like timber frame. SIP homes can never be as comfortable in the summer as an ICF house with high thermal mass.

A standard Structural Insulated Panel restricts design flexibility to a very large extent and there are many design features available in ICF that are impossible with SIP panels.

Risk of Rot and Mold: The “sandwich” assembly of SIP construction (OSB or other sheathing bonded to a foam core) can trap moisture if it gets in, leading to rot, mold, and structural damage. This is a significant concern in the UK’s damp climate.

Airtightness and Vapor Control: Because SIPs create a very airtight building envelope, proper ventilation and vapor control strategies are crucial to manage internal humidity and prevent condensation within the panels. Incorrect detailing can lead to significant moisture problems.

Moisture Traps: Unlike traditional timber frames that can “breathe” to some extent, SIPs have limited drying potential if moisture becomes trapped within the panel.

Precision Required: Proper installation and meticulous sealing of panel joints, penetrations (windows, doors, services), and the roof-wall interface are critical to prevent air and moisture leaks. This requires skilled and experienced installers.

Thermal Bridging: While the foam core provides excellent insulation, thermal bridging can occur at the timber or engineered wood splines used to connect the structural insulated panels.

Modifications: Making alterations or additions to a SIPs structure is very difficult and must be carried out by a specialist.

Services: Running electrical wiring and plumbing requires careful pre-planning and special techniques that must be followed – again requiring specialists.

While SIP construction can save time and reduce labour costs, the material costs will be higher than traditional framing, depending on the project complexity and local market.
Due to their size, SIP panels are typically difficult to transport safely and require specialised handling equipment. This significantly increases the risk of damage and cost of the transport.

Combustible Materials: The OSB (Oriented Strand Board) sheathing is a wood-based product and is combustible. While the foam core often contains fire retardants, the overall fire performance of a Structural Insulated Panel wall or roof assembly depends on the specific materials used and any additional fire protection measures that require plasterboard – thus adding more cost.

Hidden Voids: Improper installation can create hidden voids that can allow the rapid spread of fire and smoke.

Airtightness Requires Mechanical Ventilation: The excellent airtightness of SIP construction requires a well-designed mechanical ventilation system (e.g., MVHR – Mechanical Ventilation with Heat Recovery) to ensure good indoor air quality and prevent moisture buildup. This adds to the overall system cost and complexity.

Ready to design your project?

Let’s get your Home Design Plans approved and ICF ready!

Review our different design services in more detail and see how we can help get your project off the ground and built to the highest standard.

Our Design Services